Submit
Submit
Submissions are accepted on a rolling basis.
In addition to historical research papers, you can submit papers for the following categories: Historical Book or Film Review/Response, Artwork/Art History Analysis, Primary Source Analysis, Personal Narrative, and Historiographical Essay. Submission guidelines for these categories are available in the dropdown menu below labeled "Verticals Submission Guidelines."
Academic Integrity Policy
Submission to this journal does not guarantee publication.
We do not accept submissions researched or written with AI assistance.
All work should be entirely original to the author and feature proper citations.
Images, illustrations, and graphs can be included in papers, but they must have proper citation and/or permissions.
Submissions can be based on papers for class or independently written. Independently written papers should be reviewed by a history (or other relevant, history-adjacent) professor prior to submission.
Papers should have been written within roughly the last academic year.
We reserve the right to remove papers from the "On Second Thought" website and other relevant locations after publication, most notably if they are discovered to have not followed the Academic Integrity Policy.
Formatting
Body text should be double-spaced, Times New Roman, 12pt font.
Footnotes should be single-spaced, Times New Roman, 10pt font.
Block quotes should be single-spaced and indented 1 inch, not italicized.
Works Cited
All citations should be formatted as footnotes according to the most recent edition of the Chicago Manual Style.
A bibliography is not necessary.
Length and Composition
Papers should have a historical focus, but can be written for a class in any department or independently.
Papers should aim to be no more than 2500 words, and no fewer than 1500. Longer papers (such as term papers) can be submitted and may be edited down after being accepted.
Pieces should be grammatically correct and free of typographical errors.
Writing Style
Papers should be academically rigorous, but language should be relatively approachable to non-historians to maintain the journal's accessibility. Do your best to avoid excessive use of jargon, and include historical context when relevant.
Submissions should include:
Your paper, in a Google Doc. The document’s title should include your full name and OST.
A title that expresses the subject matter discussed in your paper.
An abstract of roughly 200 words summarizing the paper’s subject matter, argument, and methodology. This is not included in your paper’s word count.
Editing process
The process of editing will require input from the author. Once their papers are accepted, authors are expected to stay in touch with their editors and respond to their comments.
Lack of involvement in the editing process may result in papers not being published.
Keep in mind that submissions that do not follow the guidelines will not be considered for publication.
Historical Book or Film Review/Response
Book and Film reviews should follow OST submission guidelines in terms of formatting, and the same academic integrity policy applies.
Pieces of media reviewed or responded to can be works of historical fiction or academic historical books and documentaries.
Your work should engage with the historical background of the piece of media you are analyzing.
Papers should be no fewer than 500 words and no more than 1500 words.
Artwork/Art History Analysis
Artwork analyses should follow OST submission guidelines in terms of formatting and length, and the same academic integrity policy applies.
Images of the artwork and visual descriptions are welcome. Please use proper citations when adding images.
Primary Source Analysis
A primary source deep dive should focus on a single primary source or group of primary sources in an archive (such as the Oberlin College archive).
Primary source deep dives should follow OST submission guidelines in terms of formatting and academic integrity, but the length requirement is reduced to a minimum of 500 words.
Personal Narrative (your experience relating to history)
A Personal Narrative essay should cover a personal story or experience that relates to history.
By their nature, a personal narrative is more freeform than a standard essay and does not have to conform to a standard essay format.
Personal narratives should still follow OST submission guidelines and academic integrity standards in terms of citation (if relevant) and AI use.
Personal narratives should be no fewer than 1000 words and no longer than 2000 words.
Historiographical essay or review of a field
A historiographical essay, or a review of a field, should cover a range of secondary sources (academic papers, books, etc.) in a single field, tracing developments in the field, such as methodology or perspective.
Historiographical essays should follow OST submission guidelines in terms of formatting, and the same academic integrity policy applies.
Unlike research papers, historiographical essays should include a bibliography (in Chicago Manual style). This bibliography is not included in the word count of the paper.
For the sake of brevity, a historiographical essay should focus on a relatively narrow field of study, constrained by region and time (e.g., the field of studies in Chinese agriculture from 1950 to the present).
Historiographical essays should be no fewer than 1000 words and no longer than 2500 words.
Contact osthistory@oberlin.edu